So as the strike takes off we might need to get a little more comfortable with reality shows. Now before you groan, some of them are pretty entertaining, you just have to be a little discerning about it and you have to know what you like. And you have to be forewarned that even the bad ones can suck you in. Here are some of my rules of thumb on how I pick ‘em.
There are basically two main criteria of reality show. Straight up competitions where we might get to know the folks onstage but they don’t have to suffer through living together, or if they do we don’t see it. Think American Idol and Dancing With the Stars. And there are the ones where we get to see the behind the scenes action, either competition prep and/or interaction with the other contestants. America’s Next Top Model and Survivor both have this angle.
Now unless you are interested in the category of competition, the first style of show doesn’t quite do it. A recently launched Phenomenon where contestants compete with their magic couldn’t make this clearer. That’s not to say that behind the scenes is enough to keep it interesting, Big Brother somehow shows people in a house voting against each other for two to three nights a week, really?
So other than category what makes it interesting? I like a mix of an challenge or skill and personal dynamics. I like it when there is the possibility for an upset, we want someone to win but when it’s not a sure thing it’s much more rewarding. Good perm cast doesn’t hurt, Dave Navarro surprisingly entertains on Rock Star and though I can’t stand the Simon, Paula, Randy & Ryan group they’ve got enough going on to make their own interest. Call me un-American but I like it when someone other than America is voting, or they do a combo. And I have to admit I like the crazies, it always amazes me how real people can act more bizarre than anyone would ever believe in a fictional character.
4 Comments
I have to say I don’t really like the drama, the folks really are crazies. But I do like the competition ones, Dancing with the Stars and Idol get me every season. I love that Jennie Garth but if she can’t take it I think Helio should.
I’m not here to judge, but procrastinator, if you don’t watch “the biggest loser” you might just be that which you avoid. It’s the best (although the only) one I watch. Keep up the good work! Love the blog!
ah it’s easy to get sucked in, i’m not immune to those losers or folks who boogie, but alas there’s not enough room on the tivo for it all… I struck a pact for no new reality shows not long ago, so unless it’s premiered in the summer desperation draught I’ve tried to be strong.
I have to say what I love about the Amazing Race is seeing how people act under pressure. Some pairs are just so wide-eyed and grateful to be touring the world and usually tend to be supportive to their partners during grueling challenges (think eating brains, digging through manure, etc.) while others take this opportunity to berate their partner, screaming at them, and calling them names. And yet, they almost always stay together as a couple. I just don’t get it! So, I love it when the nice ones win. Plus, I think the diversity on this show is great.